Evident Thrown Out in Drug Case

by Vincent Lupo, Staff Writer


A small amount of marijuana found in a Moss Bluff’s couple’s home was thrown out as evidence recently by a district court judge who said the couple was “subtly coerced” into giving written permission to search their residence.

Following a seven-hour hearing conducted over two days, 14th Judicial District Court Judge Fred R. Godwin barred Assistant District Attorney Eric Roan from using the 12 grams of marijuana as evidence against   and .

Godwin said the   were coerced into signing the written consent form by the “extensive effort” the officers made in getting the couple to sign the form as well as by certain intimidating remarks the officers made about obtaining a search warrant.

The ruling ended a hearing on a motion to suppress filed by local attorney Glen Vamvoras on behalf of the  . The couple was charged with possession of marijuana after the Oct. 12, 1995, search of their home on   Road in Moss Bluff.

According to testimony elected during the hearing, the   were having a barbecue and card party for friends who were moving out of town. Reserve deputy John Tugwell, who lives in the same neighborhood, said he was taking a “cool-down” walk after jogging that night and spotted a group of people under the   lighted carport.

The deputy said what drew his attention to the group was that a cigarette was being passed around. He said he watched as the cigarette was passed twice to each person before concluding it as a marijuana joint.

Tugwell returned to his home and called the sheriff’s department. Both regular and narcotics officers came to investigate. By this time the group had gone back into the home.   was called outside and was told the reason for the investigation. Deputies said he acted shocked. When they attempted to get him to sign a form giving them permission to search the home and several cars parked there,   was reluctant. They said he asked to confer with his wife who was eventually called outside.

Deputies disagreed over the amount of time that elapsed before the   finally signed the form. Some said as little as nine minutes elapsed, while the   said at least 45 minutes passed.

Deputies admitted they told   it could take as much as two hours to obtain a search warrant if he refused to sign the form. But they were uncertain if he was told everyone in the house including the children would have to wait outside during that time.

Deputy David Judice testified it is not unusual for a deputy to wait inside and watch television with prespective arrestees while other officers leave to obtain a warrant from a judge.

Return to News Page

Need Immediate Help?

To schedule a free consultation, contact us at 337-433-1621 or through the online form below.